Circle II Circle - Watching In Silence
Circle II Circle is the new band of Zak Stevens, also known as the former singer of my favourite US Metal band, Savatage. I am one of those, who have always thought that Jon Oliva is the perfect voice for Savatage. When Zak took over the vocals in that band, I was naturally quite skeptical at the beginning, but through time he proved his worth to the band, and I got to revere his vocals as well. Obviously his voice is fantastic, smooth and contains both power and melody, but in my opinion, and even though he turned out to be awesome in Savatage, he was never able to give the songs as much character as Jon.

So now Zak has left Savatage and formed his own band, Circle II Circle. The link to Savatage is very apparant on this release, with Jon Oliva being involved in the writing and production, and Chris Caffery co-writing three songs too. Any fan of newer Savatage will feel right at home here. Not to say that Circle II Circle is a Savatage clone band, far from it. Zak succeeds in taking what he gave to Savatage with him, and uses his talent to create a great mix of Hard Rocking Metal, with a very special atmosphere. Circle II Circle is nowhere near as symphonic as the later Zak-era Savatage albums, and the Savatage album this one bears the most resemblance to must be Handful of rain.

This review is based on a promo release of the album. Unfortunately the promo is using a new "copyright protection scheme", where all the songs are merged together to form one huge track. This means that each song fades into the next and so on.

In my ears Zak has never sounded better than he does on this album. His singing is close to perfect throughout. Since his Savatage days his voice has developed to be a little deeper. Whether the music demands melody, harmony, aggression, power, or just soft silky emotion, he delivers. It is all sung with that special feeling and emotion, like we know Zak from Savatage. Good thing then, that he is also surrounded by obviously talented musicians. They are able to lay the necessary tight foundation for his voice to work it's magic. Matt La Porte and John Werner on guitars, John Zahner on keyboards, Kevin Rothney on bass and Christopher Kinder on the drums, all manage to give the songs something extra, with many small touches in the music, that show themselves more and more with each listen.

Out of reach is co-written by Chris Caffery. A heavy and powerful opener that sets the album of to a flying start. Zak shows the powerful side of his voice here, and it shows that his voice has grown since his time in Savatage. He seems to effortlessly sing everything. A good opener with some excellent harmonies in the chorus. The drums help give the song a great heavy drive.

Sea of white is also co-written by Chris Caffery. This is a heavy mid-tempo song, that has an almost dream-like quality to it. I think it's the relaxed and groovy bass playing that does it. This atmosphere reminds me a little of the feeling from John West's solo album Earth Maker.

Into the wind showcases the real strength of Circle II Circle. The way it changes pace and atmosphere several times is really excellent. The song starts out with a slow atmospheric verse, before the chorus hits you hard, with power and emotion. The brilliant and tight chorus where all the instruments work together is just amazing.

With Watching in Silence the quality raises another level. Everything works in this song, with a great melody and build-up to the chorus. This is also where I start getting a "Handful of Rain'ish" feeling, but it doesn't really matter, as long as the song is this good.

The high quality continues with fantastic songs like Face to Face, a song about coming to terms with yourself. This one has another brilliant chorus, and a very fitting guitar solo. The excellent final track Field of sorrow underlines the special atmosphere, that runs through all the songs, and the ending part finishes the album in true Savatage style!

Only a couple of songs feel a little "less good". Lies and The Circle are the ones that don't hit straight home with me. Still fine songs, but they are a little too straightforward, and need some better melodies to really hold my attention.

I also have to mention one of my favourites, Walls. A ballad with a lot of power, both in the lyrics and the music. When the chorus hits me, I can't help it, I just have to stand up and sing along... There is something life affirming about this song, and the way Zak sings here, is some of the best on the album.

The production is very good, and helps give the album it's special sound and atmosphere. Sometimes I feel that the guitar is pushed too far back in the mix though.

I would have liked some of the songs to have been a little longer, maybe to make room for some more guitar solos. The existing guitar solos are great, but they feel a little short and compact sometimes. Actually most of the songs feel very compact, but that may be just because I'm basing this on the promo, which is in fact one huge 41 minute song...

All the instruments are played extremely well. Like I mentioned there are a myriad of little touches in both guitar, bass and drums, that start showing themselves with each listen, and this helps the album grow every time I hear it. I'd heard that Jon Oliva would sing on some songs, but that is unfortunately not the case. I'm only able to hear his ominous voice in the background of Forgiven.

With this album we are treated to some fantastic songs with memorable melodies, and Zak's unique voice really rules the show. The album still grows on me with each listen, and now I'm just waiting for the limited edition of the album (Released April 28) to arrive at my doorstep. I'm sure it won't leave my Jukebox any time soon. A must buy for any Savatage fan, but I would imagine that every fan of Heavy Rock and Metal will find something to like here. There is nothing quite like it out there at the moment.

I also have a feeling that many of these songs will work excellent in a live situation. Wacken, here I come...

Written by Steen
Thursday, April 24, 2003
Show all reviews by Steen

Ratings

Steen: 8/10

Members: No members have rated this album yet.


This article has been shown 3639 times. Go to the complete list.



RevelationZ Comments











Review by Steen
None

Released by
AFM - 2003

Tracklisting
01. Out Of Reach
02. A Sea Of White
03. Into The Wind
04. Watching In Silence
05. Forgiven
06. Lies
07. Face To Face
08. Walls
09. Circle
10. Fields of sorrow


Supplied by Nordic Metal


Style
Heavy Rock/Metal

Related links
Visit the band page

Circle II Circle - Official Website

Other articles
Band information - (Steen)

Watching In Silence - (Tommy)

Watching in Silence - (Rafael)

The Middle of Nowhere - (Hashman)

The Burden of Truth - (Alanna)

Delusions of Grandeur - (Alanna)



Z supported shopping






Ratings
1 - Horrifying
2 - Terrible
3 - Bad
4 - Below average
5 - Average
6 - Good
7 - Very good
8 - Outstanding
9 - Genius
10 - Masterpiece
666 - Unrated

More details...


Daily Spotlight
D:A:D - Riskin' It All
CoverThis was my first D:A:D album and in fact the first time I really started taking notice of Rock music back in the day. 1991 t....
Read full review















Retro Reviews

(Hashman)
Yngwie Malmsteen - Facing the Animal
CoverAll hail to Mercury Records for releasing what was one of the most stand out Metal records in the nineties, which oddly enough came from a major label, especially at a time when most commercial record....
Read full review






(Tommy)
Stratovarius - Visions
CoverIn so many ways this albums represents what I would call a perfect Power Metal album, many of these songs became classics in no time and they haven't lost any of their shine. Timo Tolkki, Jari Kainul....
Read full review








Archive
 · Albums of the month
 · Retro Reviews
































Back to the top - © 2002-2011 RevelationZ Magazine - Back to the top