Ten - The Twilight Chronicles
'The Twilight Chronicles" is really, really... long, and even worse, it is quite boring in spots. Who knows what Gary Hughes was thinking when he cranked out this repetitive disc of drivel. Besides the double disc set of remakes pooped out last year, this is the worst thing Hughes has been involved in during his career thus far. And what a long and illustrious career that has been too. With several solo albums under his belt, a two disc rock opera (each part sold separately), a multitude of Ten albums that received a boatload of acclaim and adoration world round and writing three impressive albums for Bob Catley... there is no shortage of material penned and imagined by Hughes. So why is "Twilight" so utterly disappointing?

The songs are long. And I mean *long*. There have been no attempts to abbreviate anything or even spice up the proceedings. They seem to be lengthy just for the sake of it and no other reason. Themes are used, and reused, and then used yet again til annoyance turns into sheer anger and you are checking the countdown timer for the track over and over, praying that the end is in sight. He nails a nice chorus but then proceeds to loop it a zillion times in a row to stretch what should be a 3 or 4 minute track out to what seems like near infinity. Guitar solos pop in and out without much rhyme or reason, just wham bam thank you ma'am. It's disjointed and about as innovative as a rock. Not a space rock or a pebble from the beach rock, but a plain dirt covered brown, boring as hell - rock. An editor was sorely needed to slice and dice through the fat and leave the cd sleek, lean and clean. Taking it to the chop shop would have done wonders in improving the playtime and keeping the interest factor higher. You can only hear the same thing, so many times, in one bloody song before you just can't take anymore.

Yet when Hughes hits upon a great track, and leaves it with a reasonable running time, all is forgiven for those moments, and luckily there are quite a few pieces here that are not utter wastes destined for the trash heap. Towards the end of the disc the quality picks up tremendously, but trudging through those initial stinkers is a painful process that can lure you to sleep or just to extreme maddening boredom. It is a shame that a few of these great songs have been wasted on this disc even, but in favor of "Twilight", they help save it from being a total disaster on a massive scale.

The nastiest offender is plodded out like an old beaten workhorse right from the get-go. Wasting no time getting this mediocre ride off to a wobbly start is the excessively self important and hopelessly bloated "The Prologue; Rome". I swear this song must have been an hour long... yet it only lasts about twelve minutes and some change. They noodle around with instrumental "epic" stuff for almost four minutes before finally kicking into the meat of the song. Even the most progressive of bands risk losing their listener's attention with such drawn out and snooze worthy extended intros as this. If the build up cranked into something earth shattering, it would be like musical foreplay. Teasing with a bland taste before sinking into the good stuff. Only here the song being worked up to is a Ten rehash, derivative of his past works and about as fresh as a dirty gym sock with all the wretched stink that is implied.

"The Chronicles" fares much better, thriving on the blood of classic Ten pumping through its hard rock veins. It may sound like half a dozen other Ten songs, but its a welcome change after being forced to sit through the first track in its entirety. The blood is pumping and the joint is jumping with hard rock enthusiasm.

Then "Elysian Fields" pops up. There are enough ideas included here to make a nice, tight four minute track. They stretch it to seven plus. This means alot of looping and revisiting of the same worn and beaten bits repeatedly. Stick a fork in it. This one was done shortly after it got started.

Groan...'Hallowed Ground" tries to be a sweeping, haunting epic but the only thing epic about this piece is its unnecessary length. Gary wanted to pen an epic album but so far that only glimpses at the amount of time each piece drones on. There are some interesting moments sprinkled through here but the wait for the trademark pompy bridge seguewaying into chorus is too long to be worthwhile. It seems the track is going to fade around the seven min mark but keeps on chugging for another several minutes, all wasted time and regurgitating the same ideas over and over. Enough is enough already. Monotonous is the word best describing this self absorbed bit.

"This Heart Goes On" is *the* ballad and anyone that knows Ten, possesses the knowledge that Gary Hughes is like a heartthrob making the little girls swoon and weak in the knees when it comes to ballads. He is the warrior and your heart is the dragon and he sticks his sword of vanquishing right through your beating, blood spewing muscle and slays you where it hurts the most. This one is sentimental and pretty, as they all are. It is nothing new but has a consistent feel and doesn't stick around too long to wear out the welcome. The vocals are deep, throaty and seductive. Expect nothing less from this crooner.

"Oblivion" is instantly accessible, terribly addictive and the most commercial piece on the disc. It borrows a nice slab of pop flavor from "Far Beyond the World" but still links the darker taste of "Return to Evermore". The chorus is catchy as hell and tight as a drum, but is looped about ten times too many for its own good. You get worn out before the song comes to a close. Alright overall but would have been better if it had received further tweaking and streamlining.

"The Twilight Chronicles" has another nice chorus but its buried underneath so much over-the-top unnecessary theatrics (which so far have not amounted to much on this disc) and repeated themes that it falls through the cracks and is lost in the shuffle. Another one fallen to the repetition disease.

Finally they get something right...the final three songs close out the album in classy Ten style. "Tourniquet" has Hughes backing up Hughes, which is still not enough Gary for me, but vocally this sounds so powerful and massive. Layered and shivering with that classic Ten sound, it is kicked squarely in the jewels with a gritty, growling guitar. This takes the listener right off guard, especially with the haunting drifting backing vocals and acoustic accompanying it. Superb chorus here too. A little overly long, but that's forgiven since Ten keeps the song rolling with little flourishes here and there. Ten fans can trace the roots of this back to perhaps "Barricade" from "Babylon".

"Born to the Grave" is another massive hard rock track that embodies the spirit and spice of Ten. From vocals to the wicked guitar, you can feel the sweeping epic winds tumbling down the musical corridor. Five minutes even, and not a second wasted here. Chris Francis wields the axe with a heavy edge and solos right til fade for an explosive turn of events.

"When This Night is Done" is slinky, dark and moody. A slow bloomer that has a dramatic flair and drifts about like shadows in a misty night. You could call it a ballad... and that would not be far off the mark. It certainly has the feel of a ballad and the heart of a passionate romance and all its shades painted throughout. Long, but lovely and wonderful. It builds to a beautiful climax and traps the listener in its inner delicate web of longing.

"Twilight" is an album that is overly caught up in its own pompous self importance and wanders around aimlessly more often than not. A handful of interesting themes are used but after multiple reuses they fall prey to repetition and lose all their intended impact and meaning. There is a haunting undercurrent here that conjures the mystical feel of twilight - that darkened realm of soft light and stretching shadows caught between day and night. In times when this feeling is conveyed sharply in the music for brief glimpses, the disc really shines, but its an infrequent occurrence and something that doesn't really reveal itself fully, except with repeated listenings. There are songs that show the better side of the band, but overall this is a disappointment. Torn with the adoration emotion between the tracks that make the cd and battered with despair by the songs that break it, its a tug of war act that leaves the cd split right down the middle in a struggle of love and hate.

The final conclusion is this. "Twilight" is worthwhile for the dedicated Ten fan, there is more than enough here to praise and pout about. Songs such as "When This Night is Done" and "The Chronicles" should not be missed by those familiar with Hughes and his merry musicians. But for those that are just looking for a straight up great hard rock record, and that are not already in love with the band or familiar with their other works, there are a million discs on the market right now with more flash, substance and flavor than this release. Anything from Ten's back catalogue for starters if you are searching for rockers, or test out Gary's solo releases if romance is in the air. "Twilight" is for the diehards only and even then it's a tough disc to swallow more than once and still savor the taste as a complete album.

Written by Alanna
Wednesday, August 23, 2006
Show all reviews by Alanna

Ratings

Alanna: 5.5/10

Members: No members have rated this album yet.


This article has been shown 5299 times. Go to the complete list.



RevelationZ Comments


Comment by VonSeux (Anonymous) - Thursday, August 24, 2006
yeah... its a flat album. i was deffinetly waiting for something better... or different

the cover art is crap and dont matches the songs


Comment by bojach (Anonymous) - Tuesday, September 19, 2006
this was my first time listening to ten,however being a gary hughes fan, iknew i would like it...and i did...unlike some reviewers,i 'm into long tracks as long as they aren't boring......these aren't....i give it a 6/10


Comment by ISA Penguin (Anonymous) - Friday, February 2, 2007
I hoped that "The Twilight Chronicles" would be better than "Return To Evermore". This "Twilight" begins with the same style of "Spellbound", but the arrangements is poorer , in relation to Ten's albums with Vinny Burns. The only one track is cool is "The Chronicles".
It gives me the impression that Gary Hughes is not really the main songwriter ("ghostsongwriter", perhaps).

Another criticism is relationed to the album art cover: it would match Tristania's albums, Therion's, Bauhaus', Sisters Of Mercy's (all of them , Gothic-Rock Music), or, who knows, Venon's(Black Metal).... Who was the illustrator? If it was John Halliwell, where would his signature be?


I'll comment some things are not related to this average album and I'll explain why I mentioned these some things:

1. I adcquired "some bootleg videos of Ten" (2 with this band, and another one with G.H. solo).
a. On the video of solo career, his behaviour is so strange, it seems that Gary suffers from a mental pathology when he clapped his hands on the live-show in Manchester. At the same time, he seems to be insecure, and shy.
b. On "You're In My Heart", Gary seems to be drunk and tired. His eyes were morbid. He looked like goofy.

c. On "After The Love Has Gone", there are parts of live-show which he seems to be drunk (and drugged in excess)on.
As far as, he was very "skinny" (different from Ten's albums, with middle of the weight, with a bit of muscles), and he didn't tear up his white shirt (he was dressed with black trousers), in order to show his arms. Maybe you will not realize the scenes because these ones are fast and are on black & white. Excuse me for it, but I think that his kind of behaviour shows how 'songriter' is not.

After purchasing and watching these videos, I concluded that he talks he is songwriter as pop artists such as Madonna, Michael Jackson, Paris Hilton, Britney Spears.
2. And, on OAFK P1's & P2's booklets, they were said that G. Hughes played piano, guitar, programming, but on some magazines, it was written he only sang (and "songwrote") the tracks. On Ten's live-shows, he only plays accoustic guitar (typical instrument of "ghost-songwriters"). If Vinny Burns (g), Steve McKeena (b), left the band, why didn't he himself assume one of these functions? On "Precious Ones", it is said that he plays one these instruments, but on live-shows, he is not used to doing it.
Well, I 'm not also asking him to play other instruments after my comments, ok?
3. His biography, as for Music Life, seems to be an imitation of Joachim Larsson's (Joey Tempest). I mean Gary began with classical guitar, piano & drums as Joachim. It is exactly the same order!
I appointed all those comments, because I definetely meant that he does not seem to be a songwriter/composer,( as Vangelis, for instance).
Vangelis is nearly 64 years old (he is 24 years older than Gary), but he still composes pleasant music (vide "1492", "Alexander"). When that composer was 40 years old (in 1983), it was released the fantastic "Nankyoku Monogatari" ("Antarctica", for foreign countries). He has already been famous for the acclaimed "Chariots Of Fire" & "Blade Runner".
If we talk about singers-lyricists-songwriters, Ian Gillan wrote the lyrics for "Smoke On the Water", according to a pix on a Brazilian HM Magazine. So, this one can be the exception.
But, Gary can be an artist manufactured by the media. Maybe he and his management process me for these words, but the true composer always have one detached track (vide Vangelis) and would play a favourite instrument (piano, violin..., keyboard, saxophone), except accoustic guitar, For God's Sake!
Try to make a better album next time if you are really a songwriter, please!



Comment by Spiral+Girl (Anonymous) - Saturday, February 3, 2007
I've heard about that many musicians begins to play any instrument from 5 years old (or less , till 2 years old). how strange the biographies of many artists: they were said that began to study piano, guitar, when they were 9, 10 and 12.
Yesterday I read Gary Hughes' biography and it is said that he began to study guitar when he was 9 years old, and , after he studied piano.
According to instrumentalists' biography such as Vanessa-Mae's , this Chinese violinist began when she was 3. The same happened to Vangelis': he began to study piano, when he was 3. After, when he was 6, he began to ellaborate compositions (a prodige boy). I read on another biography the following: he began to study when he was 4 (I think it was a Danger Danger's member).
Well, studying guitar requires, at least, 5 years for conclusion(as other ones, too). But, I can't understand the contradiction between biographies and the moment when we see these artists at live-shows.
At least, I think that any artist should not assume as composer. It should be obrigatory how these artists compose an album on the booklet (without model-pose). Many lies , mainly for vocalists, cause me irritation. Only the instrumentalists , who are not ghost-songwriters, should assume the composition. It should be prohibited this kind of function for singers (including male vocals).
What do I mean with all these comments?
I began to untrust in Gary, because of several reasons:
1st: Gary does not play other instruments (it is not valid on albums, he should play many of them at live-shows), in addition to acoustic guitar, it means that he is not really a composer, isn't he?

2nd: The project with Ayreon, he only sings on "Beyond The Last Horizon". If he is songwriter, at least, he should have written the lyrics for the track which he performed on. Now I 've comment about this missing of his participation as lyricist, I hope that he does not do it.

3rd: He has never written powerful, amazing songs since Vinny Burns left the band.

4th : "His" project ONCE AND FUTURE KING PARTS: 1 & 2 contain several musicians. If he knows how to play guitar or keyboard, he should count neither in Arjen Lucassen's participation , nor in the guitarrists & Chris Francis' John Halliwell's (in addition to the other Ten's members) . I'll mention something that should have happened to Gary's project: Edu Falaschi, Brazilian Melodic Metal singer, Angra (name of the band), wrote a project ("Almah") and he only counted in the participation of Emppu Vuorinen, Lauri Porra, and 2 other members. Falaschi himself played the second guitar. He didn't need several instrumentalists for his project. I also hope that he does not try to change the situation.
5th: The videoclips show how goofy Gary is. A friend of mine (it is not possible to mention her name) lent me these videos, told me that he seems to suffer from mental pathology, according to a live-show, because he clapped his hand on an odd way. On other videos, his face seems to be either very drunk or very drugged . And, there is a video which he was so thin on , it seemed that he was going to fall; but, the scenes are too fast, so it is very difficult to see them. Also, on this same video, he danced as stooge person. I think his behaviour shows that he is not singer-songwriter. He only sings.
6th: the last album "The Twilight Chronicles" is not good. I really agree with the publisher Alanna.
If he is really a songwriter, he has to make a better album next. Otherwise, he has to assume that is only singer.



Comment by Brian (Staff) - Sunday, February 4, 2007
RevelationZ Staff

View Profile


Comments: 81
That's exactly what I was thinking.

Posted by Brian (Staff)
Sunday, February 4, 2007

Comment by CLIFF (Anonymous) - Tuesday, April 3, 2007
How can you lot say its crap i think its fantastic, and the long tracks really do it for me, all i can say is well done Gary your talent will always shine through











Review by Alanna

Released by
Frontiers - 2006

Tracklisting
1. Elysian Fields, Pt. 1 [Prologue]/Rome
2. Chronicles
3. Elysian Fields
4. Hallowed Ground
5. This Heart Goes On
6. Oblivion
7. Twilight Masquerade
8. Tourniquet
9. Born to the Grave
10. When This Night Is Done/The Last Moment Before Dawn (Epilogue)


Supplied by Zink


Style
Hard Rock

Related links
Visit the band page

Ten - Official Website

Ten - Ten of the best - Ten fan site

Other articles
Return to Evermore - (Alanna)

The Essential Collection 1995-2005 - (Alanna)

X - (Steen)

The Name of The Rose - (Steen)

Stormwarning - (Steen)

Stormwarning - (Steen)



Z supported shopping






Ratings
1 - Horrifying
2 - Terrible
3 - Bad
4 - Below average
5 - Average
6 - Good
7 - Very good
8 - Outstanding
9 - Genius
10 - Masterpiece
666 - Unrated

More details...


Daily Spotlight
D:A:D - Riskin' It All
CoverThis was my first D:A:D album and in fact the first time I really started taking notice of Rock music back in the day. 1991 t....
Read full review















Retro Reviews

(Steen)
Vicious Rumors - Welcome to the ball
CoverGoing through my cd collection to find this month's classic I came upon this long lost gem and it brought back a lot of great memories. The very overlooked Vicious Rumors first reared their head back ....
Read full review






(Alanna)
Danger Danger - Return of the Great Gildersleeves
CoverThere's always an album or two from a major band that seems to slip under the radar, despite critical acclaim and explosive buzz. Some ten years, after its initial rocking of the melodic rock world, <....
Read full review








Archive
 · Albums of the month
 · Retro Reviews
































Back to the top - © 2002-2011 RevelationZ Magazine - Back to the top