Article - Concept Albums Are No Mindcrime

Written by Michael Terrax

Empty room today, and here I sit.
Chalk outline upon the wall, I
Remember tracing it a thousand times
The night she died. Why?

Thus begins the penultimate track on one of the most successful metal concept albums of all time: Operation:Mindcrime by Queensryche. For the last 13 songs we have been sucked into the world of Nikki, along with the corruption, sin and perverse morality that intrudes into his junkie life. By the time the final track "Eyes of a Stranger" erupts, all we can do is reflect with him on the choices he made, and the consequences that now weigh him down.

Metal bands create songs that can, musically and lyrically, transport us to other worlds. Great metal songs deliver memorable lines and an invitation to join, albeit for a brief moment, a twist on normal existence.

These alternate universes grow in scope and realism when a collection of songs are brought together with two strong factors - theme and narrative. This is the underlying force of a concept album: to sweep the listener into a situation they have no control over; to observe and to feel; to judge but take no action. And when the final track (or last seconds of an individual track) finally fades, we still know the characters, we still mourn the tragedy. And we can relive this world over and over again.

Concept albums are not like books. Imagine you had to compress 300 pages of action, emotion and consequence into ten sparingly short poems. There is no time to dwell on the frivolous, or ponder details. Concept albums present concentrated fury, love, anger and despair, with no room for lengthy commentary or minute examination. That is why I love the concept of concept albums. The writers explore the core, and we are left to fill in the finer points.

Metal is the perfect vehicle for such an idea - our genre is so full of contrast, so resolutely intense, and at times epic, that no other music style would be able to convey the necessary spectrum of both musical and lyrical creation that a concept album must deliver.

Edge of Sanity's Crimson is the perfect example of this. From the first furious roar, to the mellower passages and onwards into the varied sections that make up this 40-plus minute masterpiece, only metal could handle the complex storyline and create a world in which a kingdom is on the precipice of annihilation, and in which the King's daughter struggles to reclaim her position. The lyrics are the narrative. The music frames the themes. This is metal in all its concept glory.

Ask any metal fan, and most would have their favourite concept album. While lyrics may not be the priority in many great metal tracks, words bring characters and dilemmas to life in concept albums. Pick one up and ask the question "What's it about?", and be prepared for an enthusiastic and comprehensive response, especially from this listener.

From a lyrical perspective, Metal is inspiring and cathartic. Metal bands that undertake the task of producing a concept album will undoubtedly travel their own journey to create and complete its story and we, the fans, are all the better for it.

This is why I'm looking forward to the sequel to "Operation Mindcrime". Through the songwriters' vision of a world that exists only in imagination, we will once more walk in the characters' shoes, see with their eyes, and hopefully be satisfied with the story arc. A world unreal becomes a world that metal fans can once again share and be part of.

Can't wait!

Michael Terrax
www.metalpoet.com - Read It Loud!


Written by Michael Terrax
Wednesday, February 15, 2006




This article has been shown 5440 times. Go to the complete list.







RevelationZ Comments


Comment by VonSeux (Anonymous) - Friday, February 17, 2006
yeah! i'm waiting to... i'm listening to Mindcrime everyday now... i hope ot does'nt disapoint us

About conceptual almbuns, i think one of the gratest is Rebellion's Macbeth: a tragedy in steel... veery good!

not to mention most of King Diamond Albums

But concept albums can be Lame, as an Example: All 3 first Freedom Call albums, the music is great and i really love it... but as a concept album it trully fails

Another Masterpiece that cannot be forgotten is W.A.S.P Crimson Idol

Witch would be the top 5 Conceptual Metal Albums ?


Comment by Steen (Staff) - Friday, February 17, 2006
Profile picture

View Profile


Comments: 518
Good question! My five favorite concept albums, where story and music come together to form something unique would be:

Savatage - Streets: A Rock Opera
Pain of Salvation - Remedy Lane
Queensrÿche - Operation: Mindcrime
Eternity X - The Edge
Shadow Gallery - Tyranny

Other concept albums that are high on my list:

Payne's Gray - Kadath Decoded
Clive Nolan & Oliver Wakeman - The Hound of The Baskervilles
Saviour Machine - The Legend Trilogy (Still not finished)
Ayreon - The Human Equation
Dream Theater - Scenes From A Memory
Most King Diamond albums (Especially Them, Conspiracy, The Puppet Master, The Eye, Voodoo, The Graveyard & House of God)
Grave Digger - Knights of the Cross

Posted by Steen (Staff)
Friday, February 17, 2006

Comment by Huachimingo Prog (Anonymous) - Saturday, February 18, 2006
Right I agree with Steen (but I like more Savatage´s Dead Winter Dead than Streets)and now I feel something special about the new Riverside album (well I cant understand the weight of the concept of the album yet because I speak spanish but the sedative prog thing is awesome)....
But you didnt mention Opeth´s Still Life !!!!!! (I need to say that :P, I dont know if you like Opeth but I am a FAN of them)

Marillion´s "Brave" and "Misplaced Childhood", Transiberian Orchestra´s "Bethovens Last Night", Spock´s Beard "Snow" and "Octane" and a few Virgin Steele albums are also in my list

Good Article and long life to the bands who really cares about make good lyrics


Comment by Michael Terrax (Anonymous) - Saturday, February 18, 2006
I'm personally a big fan of the Dream Theatre, Opeth and Ayreon concept albums listed above. In addition to those, here's a few more I've grown attached to over the years:

Fear Factory - Obsolete
Avantasia - The Metal Opera Pts 1 & 2
Ayreon - Universal Migrator Pts 1 & 2
Life of Agony - River Runs Red
Jag Panzer - Thane to the Throne

Thanks for the comments.

Michael Terrax



Comment by Steen (Staff) - Saturday, February 18, 2006
Profile picture

View Profile


Comments: 518
I know, I left out several high class albums on my list. Those I mentioned besides the top five came quickly from the top of my mind and I forgot quite a few.

Among those were:

Ayreon - The Universal Migrator I & II (Personal Favorite: The Dream Sequencer)
Opeth - Still Life (The Moor is my favorite Opeth song)
Several Virgin Steele albums (The Marriage of Heaven & Hell and Atreus trilogies)
Jag Panzer - Thane to the Throne
Savatage - Dead Winter Dead & The Wake of Magellan
Jabberwocky by Clive Nolan and Oliver Wakeman
BE and The Perfect Element by Pain of Salvation
Zodiac by Eternity X
Searching for Truth & The Inner Circle by Evergrey
Ayreon - Into The Electric Castle
Spock's Beard - Snow


Some albums where I love the music, but don't actually remember the story, which means either the story doesn't work or some elements keep the story from really captivating me or there is no actual story but an overall theme connects the songs and is used to set a specific mood.

All Rhapsody albums (Still trying to re-write The Lord of the Rings and failing completely, which is just sad since the music is amazing)
Blind Guardian - Nightfall In Middle Earth
Bob Catley - Middle Earth (The theme mostly sets the atmosphere)
The Avantasia albums
Ten - Babylon
Gary Hughes - Once & Future King I & II
Orphaned Land - Mabool
Iron Maiden - Seventh Son of a Seventh Son
Aina - Days of rising doom
Rage - Soundchaser
Iced Earth - The Glorious Burden (War theme)
Star One - Space Metal (Space Theme)
Damian Wilson - Disciple (Family/Parent theme)
Trans-Siberian Orchestra albums (Christmas theme)
Iced Earth - Horror Show (Horror theme)
Doomsword - Resound the horn (Viking theme)


A few concept albums that I eagerly await this year:

Queensrÿche - Operation: Mindcrime II
Pain Of Salvation - The Perfect Element Part II
Saviour Machine - Legend Part III:II
Vanden Plas - Christ.0

Posted by Steen (Staff)
Saturday, February 18, 2006

Comment by Mads Aanum (Anonymous) - Saturday, February 18, 2006
I really enjoy anything with a concept and most of the albums all of you have listed...

but for me one of the greates concept albums ever is Pain Of Salvation's "BE" which hase some of the best music ever, and I really like the concept as well

and also a album like Jethro Tull's "Thick as a brick" or "Songs From The Woods" are faves of mine, along with Pink Floyd's "The Wall"

Mads Aanum


Comment by Trans-Siberian Outcast (Anonymous) - Sunday, February 19, 2006
"Metal is the perfect vehicle for such an idea - our genre is so full of contrast, so resolutely intense, and at times epic, that no other music style would be able to convey the necessary spectrum of both musical and lyrical creation that a concept album must deliver."

I agree whole-heartedly with this statement. In fact, this is a very accurate description of the answer that I give people who don't understand my love of heavy metal, and ask WHY? Hard rock/heavy metal is the perfect genre for concept/theme albums because the genre has the greatest flexibility. Peaks and valleys in emotion and tempo can easily be implemented without stepping one foot outside the genre. I love it!

Steen already listed most of my favorites (no surprise there, I've been reading Revelationz for about three years and Steen's tastes match mine about 90% of the time), but here are some of my fave concept/theme albums.

Savatage - ALL
Ayreon - ALL (including spin-off projects)
Orphaned Land - Mabool
Wuthering Heights - Far From A Madding Crowd
Queensryche - Mindcrime (and hopefully II)
Miss Mercuria
Gary Hughes - Once and Future King
Nikolo Kotzev - Nostradamus
Avantasia (s)
Evergrey- Searching, Innner Circle
KISS - Music from The Elder







Comment by Steen (Staff) - Monday, February 20, 2006
Profile picture

View Profile


Comments: 518
Hey TSO!
Thanks for the reminder that I need to get hold of that Nikolo Kotzev album! :)
I remember borrowing it from a friend a long time ago and thinking there was something there, but then it disappeared from my memory until I read your comment.

Posted by Steen (Staff)
Monday, February 20, 2006

Comment by Trans-Siberian Outcast (Anonymous) - Wednesday, February 22, 2006
Hey, I'm glad my mention of Nostradamus reminded you. It feels good to give back to my man Steen, who has steered me onto so many great albums via the website! Nikolo Kotzev's album still goes mostly un-noticed even among the prog crowd, and that's a shame. With Glenn Hughes and Joe Lynn Turner sharing the bulk of the vocal duties (along with a few others like Jorn Lande and Doogie White), it's a can't miss for old school prog-rock and metal fans.


Comment by Mads Aanum (Anonymous) - Wednesday, February 22, 2006
I have that Nikolo Kotzev album... I haven't heard it since I bought it, but I guess now the time has come to listen to it again...

Mads Aanum 2006


Comment by Alanna (Staff) - Friday, February 24, 2006
RevelationZ Staff

View Profile


Comments: 245
The tracks where Jorn and Joe Lynn are mixed in together on the Nostradamus album are simply AMAZING. I listened to this endlessly, it just sucks you right in. Definitely Kotzevs greatest work yet.

My fav concept albums off the top of my head:
Nik Kotzev - Nostradamus
Shadow Gallery - Tyranny
Angel Dust - Enlighten the Darkness
Icon - Night of the Crime
Pain of Salvation - One Hour By the Concrete Lake
Savatage - Wake of Megellan
Blind Guardian - NIME
Virgin Steele - Marriage of Heaven and Hell I & II

Posted by Alanna (Staff)
Friday, February 24, 2006






Daily Spotlight
Cage - Science of Annihilation
CoverAmerican Power Metal Kings... So the Science of Annihilation cover states and I am not one to argue, in fact I am more than i....
Read full review















Retro Reviews

(Hashman)
Megadeth - Peace Sells...But Who´s Buying? - DVD Audio Edition
Cover It's about time the audiophile industry took notice of Heavy Metal, what DTS has brought forth is a more punchier, kick in the ass version of one of the most brutally aggressive thrash metal albums o....
Read full review






(Steen)
Sieges Even - Sophisticated
CoverIf I had to use one word to describe this album, it would be "Melancholic". This album has that feeling written all over it.This is Sieges Even's fourth album and my favourite. It take....
Read full review








Archive
 · Albums of the month
 · Retro Reviews
































Back to the top - © 2002-2011 RevelationZ Magazine - Back to the top